When the excavator wins (PC200, 20 t)
Mass excavation, deep trenching and steady truck loading: the PC200 digs to ~6.6 m, moves 0.80–1.17 m³ per pass and doesn't tire. If your job lives off digging — earthworks, collectors, large foundations — the excavator produces more cubic metres per day, and that pays its rate.
When the backhoe wins (WB93R / B760, 4×4)
Two machines in one rental: digs in the back (to ~5.7 m with extendable dipper) and loads in the front (~1.0 m³). If your job mixes medium trenching with material handling, backfill and cleanup — the typical utilities and housing case — the backhoe runs the whole cycle without renting two machines. And with 4×4 it moves itself between fronts.
The third option people forget
If the work is in tight space — yards, inside buildings, urban trenching next to utilities — the answer may be a mini excavator or skid-steer: they fit where the big ones can't, and rent lighter. Tell us your real access width when quoting.
Quick rule
- Digging only, high volume or depth > 5.5 m → excavator.
- Dig + load + backfill in the same shift → backhoe.
- Tight space or delicate floors → mini.
- Rock or slab to break? Either takes a breaker — ask in the same quote.
Frequently asked questions
Can I rent the excavator or backhoe with an operator?
Yes — both are available as operated rentals with a certified operator. It's the most requested option in excavation, where operator skill shows directly in progress.
Which rents cheaper?
As a general rule, the backhoe is a class below the 20-tonne excavator and its rate follows. But the number that matters is cost per cubic metre moved: in mass excavation, the excavator usually wins even at a higher rate.
Keep going