Skip to content
RentaCentro
Choosing equipment6 min read

Excavator vs backhoe: which one should you rent for your job?

By RentaCentro · Grupo ConstruMarket · Published · Updated

RentaCentro fleet 20-tonne Komatsu excavator on site

Short answer

Rent an excavator if your job is mostly digging: high volume, trenches deeper than ~5.5 m or steady truck loading — the 20 t Komatsu excavator digs to ~6.5 m. Rent a backhoe if you dig, load and backfill in the same shift: the 4×4 digs to ~5.7 m in the back and loads ~1.0 m³ up front. And if space is tight, neither: a mini excavator or skid steer.

At a glance

20 t excavator vs 4×4 backhoe, with fleet data
Spec20 t Komatsu excavatorWB93R / B760 backhoe
Weight / power20.3 t · 138 HP~99–100 HP
Digging depth~6.5 m~5.7 m (extendable dipper)
Bucket1.0 m³~1.0 m³ front + rear bucket
UndercarriageTracksWheels, 4×4
Wins atVolume, depth, truck loadingDig + load + backfill in one shift

When the excavator wins (Komatsu, 20 t)

Mass excavation, deep trenching and steady truck loading: the 20 t excavator digs to ~6.5 m, moves 1.0 m³ per pass and doesn't tire. If your job lives off digging — earthworks, collectors, large foundations — the excavator produces more cubic metres per day, and that pays its rate.

When the backhoe wins (WB93R / B760, 4×4)

Two machines in one rental: digs in the back (to ~5.7 m with extendable dipper) and loads in the front (~1.0 m³). If your job mixes medium trenching with material handling, backfill and cleanup — the typical utilities and housing case — the backhoe runs the whole cycle without renting two machines. And with 4×4 it moves itself between fronts.

Komatsu WB93R 4×4 backhoe loader
From the group's official channel: the Komatsu backhoe, digging in the back and loading up front.Official video from GrupoConstrumarket · in Spanish · plays from YouTube when you click.

The third option people forget

If the work is in tight space — yards, inside buildings, urban trenching next to utilities — the answer may be a mini excavator or skid-steer: they fit where the big ones can't, and rent lighter. The 5 t Bobcat E50z has zero tail swing and digs to ~3.5 m right against the wall. Tell us your real access width when quoting.

Bobcat E50z zero-tail-swing mini excavator
Quick rule: which machine to rentDigging only, high volume or deeper than 5.5 m: 20 t excavator. Dig + load + backfill in the same shift: 4×4 backhoe. Tight space, yard or delicate floor: Mini excavator or skid steer. Rock or slab to break: Either one + breaker.Quick rule: which machine to rentDigging only, high volume or deeper than5.5 m→ 20 t excavatorDig + load + backfill in the same shift→ 4×4 backhoeTight space, yard or delicate floor→ Mini excavator or skid steerRock or slab to break→ Either one + breaker

Cost per cubic metre, not per hour

As a general rule, the backhoe is a class below the 20-tonne excavator and its rate follows. But the number that matters is the cost of each cubic metre moved: in mass excavation, the excavator usually wins even at a higher rate, because it makes more passes per hour with a bigger bucket. On mixed jobs, the backhoe wins because it saves you a second machine and its freight.

Rock or slab to break?

Both take a hydraulic breaker: the fleet has a 20 t excavator configured with breaker hydraulics, and the breakers mount on the backhoe, with or without the rented backhoe. Ask for it in the same quote so it arrives with hydraulics and coupler ready.

What to give when quoting so you get the right machine

  • Depth and width of the trench or cut.
  • Approximate volume and whether trucks need loading.
  • Type of ground: soil, rock or slab to break.
  • Real access width and whether there are lines or utilities nearby.
  • Days of digging and whether you want an operator.

Common mistakes

  • Renting the 20 t excavator for a small trench in an urban space: it won't fit or won't pay off.
  • Using a backhoe for mass excavation: it costs more per cubic metre.
  • Not measuring the access width before quoting.
  • Forgetting the breaker and asking later: it comes on another trip.

Frequently asked questions

Can I rent the excavator or backhoe with an operator?

Yes — both are available as operated rentals with a certified operator. It's the most requested option in excavation, where operator skill shows directly in progress.

Which rents cheaper?

As a general rule, the backhoe is a class below the 20-tonne excavator and its rate follows. But the number that matters is cost per cubic metre moved: in mass excavation, the excavator usually wins even at a higher rate.

Which one digs deeper?

The 20 t Komatsu excavator: to ~6.5 m. The 4×4 backhoe reaches ~5.7 m with its extendable dipper, and the E50z mini excavator ~3.5 m.

What works best in a tight space?

A zero-tail-swing mini excavator (Bobcat E50z), which digs right against the wall, or a Bobcat skid steer for loading and cleanup. Tell us the access width when you quote.

How does the machine get to my site?

We coordinate transport with delivery: lowboy mobilization, safe lifting and a documented inspection on arrival. Freight is quoted by distance and access.

Equipment in this guide

Add them to your quote with the + button and send them together, with dates, in a single request.

Also on the site

Keep going

Keep reading

All guides

What equipment does your project need?

Tell us what you need and for how long. We'll reply with a clear proposal — no fine print.

Quote your equipment
Get a quote